Why You Should Stop Exercising to Lose Weight

A woman happily disposing of her weight scale.

This was originally posted on U.S. News & World Report's webiste.

If I've said it once, I've said it a thousand times: Exercising for the primary goal of losing weight will not help most people stick with exercise over time. It may get you to start, but it most likely sets you up to exercise in ways that you don't like. As a result, you'll stop once you get tired of forcing yourself to adhere to this regimen and feel like a failure – again. Not only do you not achieve your weight-loss goal, but you also miss out on the multitude of benefits of being active.

My studies are not the only research supporting this contention. Other behavioral researchers also find that focusing on weight loss is far from the most strategic way to stay motivated to enjoy and benefit from regular physical movement. For example, one recent study on fitness centers found that people motivated to exercise by weight loss go to the gym less frequently than those with different goals.

What's more, a parallel (and growing!) body of knowledge in the biological sciences aligns with this perspective; it suggests that physical activity is generally an ineffective tool for losing weight. Take one recent study, for instance, in which researchers investigated almost 2,000 people in different countries over five years and found that physical activity was not necessarily a shield against weight gain.

Even Martin Gibala, the founder of high-intensity interval training (a type of exercise involving short bursts of all-out exercise), doesn't necessarily endorse fitness as a clear route to weight loss. "In general, exercise is not a huge contributor to weight control. People don't like to hear that, but it's true," he said in a recent New York Times story. "It is much easier to cut calories in the diet than to burn large numbers of them with exercise of any kind."

On top of that, Kevin Hall, a leading weight-loss scientist at the National Institutes of Health, told Vox last year, "Exercise isn't a weight-loss tool for health. It's excellent for health. It's the best single thing you can do after you stop smoking to improve your health. But don't look at it as a weight-loss tool."

You and your health professionals might be alarmed by the idea that what you've always been told – that exercise is an important way to lose weight – sets most of us up to fail most of the time. But more and more professionals who work in health, wellness and fitness discover the same thing: The goal of "weight loss" doesn't help most of their patients and clients stay motivated over time. Put bluntly: When you're told you should exercise for weight loss, you probably won't stick with your physical activity program – even though you actually want and intend to do so.

How many times are you going to approach taking better care of yourself with a strategy that has failed numerous times in the past? If this most common and traditional approach to physical activity doesn't keep most of us motivated, isn't it time for all of us – including you and your health care team – to pause and wonder whether we should ditch it? If you truly want to be consistently more active and take better care of yourself, start thinking about physical activity in a new way.

Science shows that what works most consistently is what feels good now – not something that feels like hard work or punishment, even if you're doing it for a great reason. If you want to motivate yourself or others to strive for a distant goal like weight loss and health, you need to translate it into its immediate influence on life today. Even marketing guru Seth Godin agrees. He says that if you want to motivate people to strive for a future-oriented goal, you actually need to figure out how to convert it into "how it feels right now." Enough said.

So Instead of dragging yourself to the gym because you want to lose weight, consider how moving makes you feel. For example, do you tend to feel an energy boost? Do you sleep better? Does your stress go down? Make those your reasons for exercise – and watch your desire to exercise increase. The irony is that when you start taking better care of yourself in order to feel better in the now, you'll set yourself up to better cultivate good health in the future.


Why Exercise Is Just Like Sex

Nobody looks forward to the same old boring meal every day or a night of bad sex. Most of us take these uncomfortable moments as one-offs and course correct for fun and variety as quickly as possible. Or we simply stop desiring it. Yet far too many people still think or exercise as something they […]


Five Fitness Strategies to Feel Great this Fall

This is a true belief that unfortunately most people don’t yet believe:  All types and any duration of movement you can fit into your day COUNTSs toward revitalization, fueling joy, supporting good health and restoring your sense of yourself. Use these five strategies to discover how you can find time for physical movement on even […]

Fall fitness, Fall fitness

Sparks from the torch of POS ignite new ideas in positive health care and beyond

I am not an athlete or even a sports fan. Yet, in 1992, I not only became an employee of the Olympic Committee in Spain, I had the honor of carrying the Olympic Torch. I ran through cheering crowds and passed the torch to the next runner, helping it on its way to light the […]

Center for Positive Organization, Olympic Torch

Want to Improve Patient Health? Stop Promoting Health!

Health promoters need a better hook than “health” if they want patients to actually achieve better health. This suggestion may seem paradoxical and even downright heretical. But a quick reality check with those who have tried and failed repeatedly to stick to a health-motivated exercise or diet plan (maybe even yourself!) will reveal the truth: […]

A New Spring in My (Next) Steps!

Do you know what happens after someone publishes a book that represents their last 20 years of Purpose? I’ve been trying to answer that question myself ever since No Sweat was published last summer. I wondered if I would ever have this sort of energizing passion in my life again. Researching what fosters lasting motivation […]

How to Plant the Motivational Seeds for a Physically Active Lifestyle

This content was originally posted on the US News & World Report’s blog. Spring is a lovely time of longer days, more sunshine and the call of the great outdoors. It’s also a wonderful, natural lab in which you can experiment with physical activity. Take time now to plant the seeds of lifelong fitness motivation […]

The Perfect Fitness Plan for Every Mindset

This content was originally posted on the US News & World Report’s blog. We’re all different in how we approach planning, including when it comes to fitness. Some of us are more comfortable knowing we have a well-structured routine, some of us prefer a free-form approach and others mix it up – with some days […]

Why February Is the Best Time to Recalibrate Your New Year’s Resolutions

This content was originally posted on the US News & World Report’s blog. If you took my advice to heart last month, you ditched those old New Year’s resolutions that never worked. Instead, you made some great new resolutions based on the right whys, and you gave yourself permission to take time for your own […]

3 Things People Who Stick to Their New Year’s Resolutions Do Differently

This content was originally posted on the US News & World Report’s blog. Here’s my advice for 2016: Stop making the same resolution every year and expecting to get a different result. If “willpower, dieting and workouts” has been your mantra year after year – and year after year you lose the will, tire of […]